Love & Mercy

Love & Mercy photo starrating-4stars.jpgCo-founder of the Beach Boys, Brian Wilson gets the biographical treatment in Love & Mercy. Taking its name from a song off his 1988 self titled solo album, the picture is an engrossing portrait of a complicated man. A complex man deserves a likeminded biography and as such, the production submits his life as two halves, each played by a different person.

In the 1960s the chronicle shows Wilson as the mastermind behind the unique California sound of the Beach Boys which culminated in the critically revered Pet Sounds in 1966. Actor Paul Dano embodies the very talented young man who endured a rough childhood at the hands of a hard-hearted father (Bill Camp). Music was a creative outlet. The group comprised his two younger brothers Dennis and Carl (Kenny Wormald and Brett Davern), their cousin Mike Love (Jake Abel) and friend Al Jardine (Graham Rogers). Together they poured their hearts into song with Brian as their primary composer. The chronicle presents the songwriter as a gifted genius struggling to reconcile the “voices in his head” and then put that into music. Wilson had several nervous breakdowns. Paul Dano has a quality that lends itself to Brian Wilson’s off kilter personality.

The other half of his life takes place in the 80s when Brian Wilson was diagnosed with depression and schizophrenia. From the start, he is already under the care of “psychologist to the stars” Eugene Landy (Paul Giamatti). Landy has an around the clock presence in the musician’s life. Wilson meets car saleswoman Melinda Ledbetter (Elizabath Banks), one day while shopping for a Cadillac. The two strike up a relationship. An actress usually known for playing comedic parts, the dramatic weight is a stark contrast to the roles she usually plays. Banks is a revelation. A nurturing presence, she is a foil to Landy’s svengali like control. Her speechless reactions while Landy barks at Wilson, perfectly conveys her growing unease with the situation. Landy clearly sees Wilson’s burgeoning romance with Ledbetter as a problem. She becomes a calming force. I will admit that the story could have just as easily been told from Landy’s point of view and dismissed Ledbetter as a gold digger. This is not the case, however. Landy is vilified as a doctor with no redeeming qualities. The portrait then begs the unanswered question, how did this particular man obtain so much authority over Wilson’s life?

Love & Mercy wisely narrows its focus. By staging the existence of Brian Wilson as two separate people, we get a richer appreciation for the complexities of the man. It puts distance between two stages of his life. Paul Dano is particularly good as the younger Wilson. It’s easier to accept him as the talent that guided the Beach Boys because he looks quite a bit like the guy. He does a great job portraying his musical obsessions in a very natural way. John Cusack has a harder time because his long face and dark hair deviate so sharply from the physical features of the actual person. It’s an interesting idea though. Cusack’s mannered performance highlights a compelling soul. Two sides that link one man, unite the story as it jumps back and forth between the past and the present. His mental illness compounded by abusive people, first by his father and then his doctor. Through it all we get glimpses into the creative process. Love & Mercy effectively depicts the hidden torment behind some of the 60s most uplifting music. Thankfully it’s not all misery. In the 80s, it’s his bond with Ledbetter that gives us hope with his troubled life. Elizabath Banks is that oasis of calm that compels you to watch.


15 Responses to “Love & Mercy”

  1. Thanks for the great review, Mark! Makes me even more excited to see this, especially Paul Dano, and Paul Giametti always brings brilliance to the table.

    Am listening to “Pet Sounds” for the VERY first time–can’t get past Wouldn’t It Be Nice (!!)


  2. The cast is great, but these biopics are starting to get a tad bit stale now. Nice review.


  3. smilingldsgirl Says:

    I like that they tried to do something different. Not everything worked but I loved the creating the music part. That was brilliant. It is a weird movie that combined a biopic and thriller into one movie. It feels a little wedged at times but I did like it.


  4. Stellar review Mark, you’ve put into words what I’ve truly loved about this film; the way it split the life into two parts, one maybe slightly more compelling than the other — but both rich in detail and emotion. I think I glossed over Banks’ impact in my review b/c I was so in love with the mood this film put me in. But no doubt about it, she was great.


    • It was very emotional. The story could’ve focused more on the music and that might have been great too but it took a different route. I always take the facts of these biographies with a grain of salt, but needless to say this was captivating.


  5. abbiosbiston Says:

    This sounds great. I grew up with The Beach Boys and I’m excited to find out more about Brian Wilson.


  6. This was my favorite movie so far this year.


  7. As a big fan of the Beach Boys, I’ve been looking forward to seeing this movie. I’m glad to hear that you liked it. I think the choice to have Dano and Cusack portray Wilson at different points is an interesting one. I don’t always care for Dano, but I usually enjoy Cusack. I was aware of Wilson’s troubled background and personal life, although I wasn’t aware of the volatile relationship he seemed to have with his doctor. The push and pull of Giamatti’s character with Banks’s character for Wilson’s attention sounds like it makes for compelling drama.


    • It was. I will offer this observation, however. His doctor, Eugene Landy, passed away on March 22, 2006. It always seems a bit unfair when a portrait this negative is presented on someone who cannot defend themselves.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: