The Gift

The Gift photo starrating-4andahalfstars.jpgSimon is a highly competitive, status-conscious go-getter. His wife Robyn is interested in restarting her successful architect business. Jason Bateman and Rebecca Hall are the Callums, a well-to-do couple who have recently moved from Chicago to suburban Los Angeles. They’ve bought a sleek glass-walled home in the hills near where Simon grew up. They seemingly have the perfect life. However a recent miscarriage hangs over them. Then one day while out shopping for furniture for their new home, a man approaches Simon and claims to know him from high school. Simon doesn’t recognize him until he says his name is Gordon Mosely, or Gordo.

Their exchange is pleasant, but soon after, he begins dropping by their home unannounced, usually when Simon is at work. Then there’s the series of escalating presents that Gordo bestows on the pair: a bottle of wine, koi fish for their outdoor pond. His presence starts to make them uncomfortable. Dismantling the peaceful tranquility of the wealthy suburban upper-class is a genre unto itself. Call it the “home-invasion” thriller. Fatal Attraction, Pacific Heights, The Hand That Rocks the Cradle, Single White Female and Unlawful Entry have all done the broad category justice. The Gift is an impressive addition.

The cast is uniformly excellent. I generally consider Jason Bateman to be a comedic actor, but he plays against type occasionally.  Once again, he is outstanding in a serious role. Rebecca Hall is his equal as yes, his sympathetic wife. But she’s a complex individual in her own right. They don’t always see eye to eye. Together they must contend with this intruder in their lives. Joel Edgerton (WarriorThe Great Gatsby) strikes the perfect balance between menacing and amiable as Simon’s classmate from the past. Edgerton is also the writer and director. He delivers an extremely self assured directorial debut with this finely crafted feature.

The Gift is a suspense thriller that hews close to the grand tradition of Alfred Hitchcock. The chronicle commences with a predicable frame, but it doesn’t end that way. What energizes the story is how Edgerton’s screenplay extracts tension from the unknown. That queasy feeling you get when things are a bit off kilter but you’re not really quite sure why. That lack of privacy is at the heart of the horror exploited here. Their personal refuge is being infringed to the point that it becomes unsettling. What makes Gordo tick is a question you’ll immediately have once he becomes part of the narrative. The script takes it’s time not to answer this question immediately. The drama allows the audience to simmer for awhile in this sinister stew. I didn’t realize how much I enjoy being on edge. By the shocking climax, The Gift pushes you to the absolute brink.



24 Responses to “The Gift”

  1. I saw this the week it opened and have still been meaning to write a review for it (same with M:I-5 and Straight Outta Compton). Didn’t like this nearly as much as you did, though. I thought it was full of clichés and the character development really threw me off. Plus there were a lot of plot points that didn’t even need to be there in the first place. Good acting, though. I’d give it like a 2.5/5.

    Oh and I actually thought the climax was rather predictable.

    Liked by 1 person

    • The climax was just the icing on a malevolent cake. It wasn’t just about the finish. The dread kept expanding throughout the film. A slow burn thriller as they say.

      Liked by 2 people

    • I’m with you on this. I see quite a few just thinking this is such a suspenseful thriller, and while I liked it..liked the 1st effort by Egerton on writing, directing AND acting in it.. I found it the same as utterly predictable. But then we all see things differently..I’m just glad to see I’m not the only one who thought this Cinemaniac!!! 😀

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Horror has really stepped up its game. I must add this to my ‘Must See Immediately’ list.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. GaryGreg828 Says:

    I agree. I liked it, as well. Lot of tension and wasn’t predictable. The finale wasn’t as shocking as I was hoping, like in “Orphan” but it fit the story; and this is one of those that you like it more, the more you think about it after you leave the theater. I think this is the first film I saw at the theater since Mad Max. Nothing this summer has interested me. This is the only film to do so this season.

    Speaking of thriller, you haven’t been to my blog in a while. I’ve only posted 2 entries the last couple months, but you need to go on there and check out my “Creep” entry (my second-to-last entry).

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Elated to see you enjoyed it so much too. I think Joel Edgerton could have a very successful career both in front of and behind the camera. I just loved this, a favorite of mine of 2015

    Liked by 1 person

  5. A Tale of Two Dans Says:

    We totally agree about everything regarding this movie, even the rating 😂
    You’re spot on though I never thought I’d love being on the edge as much either and then this movie comes along


  6. Great comparisons you mentioned. There is a little of each in this film. I loved it. I especially loved how the ending keeps you guessing. Not predictable, at all. 4 1/2 stars


  7. Loved it as much as you did. The way it flips genre conventions about a third of the way through was unexpected. I also thought this was highly unpredictable.

    Trailer made the film seem generic, but in this case, I think it was intentional. It really gives little to nothing away. One of my favorites of the year.


    • A good trailer should present the set-up, but not give any story developments away. I no longer even watch trailers anymore. The great majority give away too amny details that ruin the surprise of watching the film.

      Liked by 1 person

      • You’re absolutely right. I hardly ever go out of my way (i.e, YouTube) to view the latest trailer, but I just think it is hard to avoid them in the theater without deliberately coming right before the show starts. I guess I’m more traditional; I like getting to my seat a few minutes before the run of previews begin.

        I know that some advance screenings don’t show them, which is awesome.


  8. Fantastic write-up! I can’t wait to check this one out. Been hearing only great things about Edgerton’s debut behind the camera.


  9. Rachel Wagner Smilingldsgirl Says:

    Too scary for me. Well made but not my cup of tea you could say.


    • It was creepy to be sure, but I never found it scary.


      • Rachel Wagner Smilingldsgirl Says:

        I think being a single woman the idea of a stalker and a woman being raped is very scary


      • Rachel Wagner Smilingldsgirl Says:

        How do you define the difference between creepy and scary? I think everyone has those sensitive spots that really scare them (some scared of heights, others snakes, others being alone etc). For me it is anything with women being raped, murdered or stalked.


  10. I agree that The Gift is an impressive addition to the “home invasion” thriller genre and that the cast is uniformly excellent. Bateman is fantastic playing against type and Rebecca Hall gives a complex performance. You’re right that Joel Edgerton strikes the perfect balance between menacing and amiable. His directorial debut is very self-assured and this feature is finely crafted. I love how the film starts out so conventionally and then completely subverts your expectations as it goes on. I also enjoyed how much The Gift kept me on edge.


    • I love when low budget films (a production budget of $5 million in this case) make significantly more than they cost. Box office: $43.8 million. Means we’ll get more gems like this.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: